Physiology Before Psychology

TL;DR: Physiology Before Psychology

What if our thoughts and emotions are not always the cause of our physiological responses, but consciousness attempting to make sense of what is already happening in the body?

Through decades of experiencing multiple sclerosis, night terrors and sudden involuntary breathing episodes, I came to recognise a recurring pattern:

Physiological event → Embodied experience → Conscious construction of meaning.

During night terrors, an overwhelming bodily sense of impending death became a vivid narrative of physical danger. During waking episodes, a sudden physiological disturbance produced the same underlying sense of danger, followed by thoughts of everyday catastrophe.

The experience came first. The explanation followed.

Interoceptive neuroscience provides a scientific framework for understanding this process. The brain continuously senses, predicts and regulates the body's internal state, much of it outside conscious awareness. What we experience as emotion or thought emerges within this ongoing embodied process.

This has profound implications for psychotherapy. If a frightening thought is the mind's interpretation of an existing physiological state, changing the thought may not address what generated the experience.

The central insight: Physiology generates experience. Consciousness constructs meaning.

Understanding this relationship invites us to approach emotional distress not simply as a problem of thinking, but as an embodied experience involving the whole nervous system.


Physiology Before Psychology: Interoception, Embodied Emotion and the Construction of Conscious Experience

An exploration of how the nervous system generates experience and consciousness constructs meaning

Introduction

Cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) frequently conceptualises emotional experience through the relationship between thoughts, feelings and physiological responses. Within this framework, the interpretation of an event can generate an emotional response, accompanied by corresponding changes in the body.

But what if this sequence fundamentally misunderstands the relationship between physiology and consciousness?

What if the nervous system generates an experience of danger before conscious thought has identified anything threatening? And what if the thoughts that follow are not the cause of the experience, but consciousness attempting to explain what the body is already experiencing?

This question lies at the heart of interoceptive neuroscience, the study of how the nervous system senses, integrates and interprets the body's internal condition.

It also provides a framework for understanding experiences I have observed over several decades, involving multiple sclerosis, severe night terrors and sudden involuntary breathing episodes.

The central proposition is that consciousness is fundamentally embodied and interpretive. Our conscious experience emerges from physiological and neural processes already underway, rather than existing independently of them.

Night Terrors and Neurological Events

For more than twenty years, I experienced episodes of extraordinarily intense night terrors.

During these episodes, I would partially awaken with an absolute conviction of imminent death. The experience was not simply fear. It was a profound, bodily certainty that death was about to occur.

My mind would construct vivid explanations for this sensation. The ceiling was about to collapse. A crack in the wall meant the building was falling. On several occasions, I perceived an enormous train approaching through my bedroom, filling the entire space and leaving no possibility of escape.

These experiences were so convincing that I acted upon them. During one particularly severe episode, I smashed my way through a bedroom window, sustaining injuries that required hospital treatment.

Following my diagnosis of multiple sclerosis (MS), I began recognising a relationship between these night terrors and my neurological attacks.

The night terrors were not warnings of attacks yet to come. My understanding was that the night terror was the MS attack in action: the conscious experience of an acute neurological event occurring in real time.

The transition was immediate and overwhelming, like being plugged into the electrical mains. Afterwards, I would experience new neurological symptoms, including limb numbness or severe cognitive dysfunction, which persisted for weeks.

Over time, I came to understand the terrifying imagery as consciousness attempting to explain an extraordinary physiological experience.

My nervous system was undergoing a profound disturbance. The experience of danger was already present. In the partially dreaming state, my mind constructed an explanation proportionate to its intensity: certain, unavoidable death.

The precise neural processes involved in these episodes were not measured at the time. That question is distinct from the relationship between physiological disturbance and conscious interpretation that I recognised through repeated experience.

The Same Pattern in Waking Consciousness

In 2021, following two AstraZeneca COVID-19 vaccinations, I experienced a marked change in my physiological stress responses. I subsequently contracted COVID later that year.

A new phenomenon emerged, which I called anxiety breath, although I had no history of anxiety and the episodes were not responses to stressful circumstances.

Each episode began with a sudden, involuntary sharp inhalation. Almost simultaneously, an intense bodily sensation of impending danger arose.

Only then would a conscious explanation appear.

I might suddenly think that I was going to lose my job, be evicted, or experience some other catastrophe.

The thought had no necessary relationship to my circumstances. It appeared to be consciousness finding an explanation for an internal sensation that had already occurred.

At their worst, these episodes happened several times daily. They have since diminished considerably.

Although the breathing episodes and night terrors were not identical, I recognised the same underlying pattern:

Physiological event → Embodied experience of danger → Conscious construction of meaning.

During sleep, the mind constructed dramatic imagery of physical death. During wakefulness, it generated brief narratives of everyday catastrophe.

The content differed, but the interpretive process appeared remarkably similar.

Interoception: The Scientific Framework

Interoception is the process through which the nervous system senses, integrates and interprets signals arising from within the body.

These include information about breathing, cardiovascular activity, visceral sensations, temperature, metabolic conditions and immune processes.

Importantly, much of this activity occurs outside conscious awareness.

Khalsa and colleagues (2018) describe interoception as fundamental to bodily regulation, survival, emotional experience and cognition.

This establishes an important principle: emotion is not simply a psychological response imposed upon the body. It is inseparable from the nervous system's representation and regulation of bodily states.

Neuroscientist Anil Seth (2013) developed the concept of interoceptive inference, describing emotions as emerging through the brain's interpretation and prediction of internal bodily signals.

Barrett and Simmons (2015) further developed this understanding through their model of embodied predictive interoception.

In this framework, the brain continuously anticipates the body's physiological needs, processes incoming signals and adjusts its predictions and regulatory responses.

Conscious experience emerges within this ongoing process.

The brain is not passively receiving information from the body. It is actively involved in predicting, regulating and interpreting physiological states.

This means that a feeling of danger need not begin with a conscious thought about danger.

It can arise through neural processes involved in bodily regulation and threat detection, with conscious interpretation subsequently providing an explanation.

The relationship between body and consciousness is therefore not simply a one-way progression. It is a continuous, reciprocal system involving physiology, nonconscious processing, conscious interpretation and behavioural regulation.

Nevertheless, conscious thought is not necessarily the initiating event, even when it becomes the most recognisable part of the experience.

Consciousness as Interpreter

This understanding leads to a broader proposition about human experience.

Consciousness may be understood as an interpretive process arising within an already active, embodied nervous system.

Our brains continuously process information, regulate physiological functions, anticipate events and prepare responses before those processes become available to conscious awareness.

What we experience as a thought or emotion may therefore be the conscious expression of a process that began outside awareness.

The night terrors provide a particularly vivid illustration.

The experience of imminent death was present before the mind supplied an explanation. The collapsing ceiling or approaching train was not the origin of the terror. It was the narrative through which consciousness made sense of it.

Similarly, during the breathing episodes, the thought of losing my job did not initiate the physiological event. It followed the involuntary breath and bodily experience of danger.

This distinction challenges the assumption that the conscious narrative necessarily reveals the cause of an emotional experience.

The story we tell ourselves about a feeling may be an interpretation of its origin, rather than its origin itself.

Implications for Psychotherapy

This understanding has significant implications for psychotherapy.

Cognitive approaches, including cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT), frequently work with the relationships between thoughts, feelings and behaviour.

Such approaches can be effective. However, a model that assumes distress originates primarily in conscious interpretation risks overlooking the physiological processes from which the experience may emerge.

If a person's nervous system generates an intense experience of danger, the accompanying catastrophic thought may be a consequence rather than the initiating cause.

Changing that thought may influence the ongoing regulatory process, but it does not necessarily address what initially generated the experience.

This raises important questions about therapeutic mechanisms. The effectiveness of cognitive interventions does not establish that cognition was the original cause of distress. Therapeutic relationships, behavioural changes, physiological regulation and shifts in attention may all contribute to improvement.

Interoceptive neuroscience therefore supports a more integrated understanding of psychotherapy, one that recognises the inseparability of bodily regulation, emotion, consciousness and relationship.

It also provides a scientific foundation for investigating somatic approaches that attend directly to physiological experience rather than treating bodily sensations merely as consequences of thought.

Conclusion

Decades of observing neurological events, bodily sensations and conscious experience led me to recognise a fundamental relationship:

Physiology generates experience. Consciousness constructs meaning from that experience.

Contemporary interoceptive neuroscience provides a sophisticated framework for understanding this relationship.

The brain continuously senses, predicts, interprets and regulates the body's internal condition. Emotional experience emerges through these embodied processes, much of which takes place outside conscious awareness.

The precise mechanisms of individual neurological events may require further investigation, but this does not diminish the established importance of interoception in emotion and consciousness.

The broader implication is profound.

Rather than understanding the body as responding to an independently operating mind, we can understand conscious experience as emerging from the activity of an embodied nervous system.

Our thoughts are part of that process, but they are not necessarily its beginning.

Sometimes what we believe we are frightened of is not what caused the fear. It is the explanation consciousness has constructed for a physiological experience already underway.

References

Barrett, L. F., & Simmons, W. K. (2015). Interoceptive predictions in the brain. Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 16, 419–429. https://doi.org/10.1038/nrn3950

Khalsa, S. S., et al. (2018). Interoception and mental health: A roadmap. Biological Psychiatry: Cognitive Neuroscience and Neuroimaging, 3(6), 501–513. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bpsc.2017.12.004

Seth, A. K. (2013). Interoceptive inference, emotion, and the embodied self. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 17(11), 565–573. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tics.2013.09.007

Next
Next

The Start of a New Term at Uni